As a conservative you would think that a FOX News host telling you
that the latest Republican attempt to defund Obamacare by threatening a
government shutdown is “a very destructive, unwise strategy” that
“smacks of political mummery”, would give you pause for thought.
For conservative commentator and Washington Times columnist Monica
Crowley that was too much to ask for. Despite being told by FOX News
host Gregg Jarrett that evidence from three separate opinion polls
indicates that a shutdown would be blamed on Republicans, Crowley
apparently believes that this is a price worth paying because “you don’t
surrender the nation to socialized medicine just because you think that
you can’t win the PR battle.”
Perhaps the most interesting moment came when Jarrett claimed that
Boehner and the rank and file GOP actually had little interest in
pursuing the defunding of Obamacare. Was it not just the case that they
were being “held hostage” by the Tea Party over this, and were
attempting to appease the more reactionary elements in their party?
Crowley did not seem too interested in addressing that, instead claiming
that “50%-60%” of Americans “hate” Obamacare and that “the country is
with us on this.”
Jarrett also tried to appeal to Crowley’s sense of realpolitik; surely she must
concede that any attempt to defund Obamacare would never make it past
the Democrat-controlled Senate, and even if it did, President Obama
would resign before he dismantled his signature healthcare law? Ms.
Crowley did concede that, saying that defunding Obamacare is “highly
unlikely”, but that doesn’t matter because, apparently this puts
political pressure on the Democrats. A rather bizarre conclusion given
the polling data Crowley had been shown earlier.
The moment to switch off for many of us came when Crowley pivoted to
that old conservative favorite: the “corrupt media”, and its inevitable
plan to spin all of this to make it look like Republicans were being
reckless and actively pursuing a shutdown. Ms. Crowley has nothing to
worry about: a media, corrupt or not, would not struggle at all at the
moment to make the GOP look reckless.
Just one small coda to all this: Crowley seems to be slightly
confused. The United States does not have “socialized medicine.” That is
what they have here in Britain in the form of the National Health
Service. The health system is funded by the tax payer meaning it is free
at the point of service for all who need it (even non-British citizens
who are injured or hurt while in the UK are entitled to free emergency
health care). What America has is a system that preserves the role of
the market in providing healthcare, but now protects against excessive
charges and premiums, with the government there to subsidize those
Americans who cannot afford healthcare coverage.
No comments:
Post a Comment